i9 Intelligence vs. Workday's I-9 module

Workday runs HR at large employers, and its I-9 is one business process inside onboarding. It falls short on ICE audits, TPS and asylee cases, and the audit record itself, which we saw in a customer's tenant in September 2026. Our pre-built Workday connector keeps the I-9 with the team that has done nothing else for 28 years.

Facts checked
October 8, 2026
Sources
We make i9 Intelligence. Found something out of date?
Our product · Form I-9 specialist

i9 Intelligence

Starting price
$50/mo, tiered by hires per year
Remote Section 2
Free with your own authorized representative; our team $50
Add i9 Intelligence if…
  • You want a team that has helped employers through ICE audits for 28 years, before an inspection notice ever arrives.
  • Your workforce includes TPS holders, asylees, refugees, or workers on automatic work permit extensions, and you want those I-9s handled by specialists.
  • You want entries checked as they're typed, so a 900-series Social Security number or a citizen with a List C EAD gets caught before Section 2 is signed.
  • You want Workday to stay your HR system, with the I-9 running alongside it through a pre-built connector.
  • You sometimes hire remotely and want a trained team, or a manager you choose, to complete Section 2.
vs.
HCM or payroll suite

Workday's I-9 module

Starting price
Not published. Part of your Workday contract.
Remote Section 2
Your managers or an authorized representative you arrange
Workday alone is enough if…
  • You hire in person, rarely need reverification, and your managers are trained on Workday's I-9 tasks.
  • You want every onboarding step, including the I-9, in one system with one login.
  • Your Workday partner has configured and tested your I-9 business processes and reports.

Side by side

Workday's details come from our September 2026 review of a customer's Workday I-9 setup. Configurations vary.

i9 IntelligenceOur productWorkday's I-9 moduleOnboarding business process in Workday HCM
Product typeSpecialist. Form I-9 and E-Verify only, since 1998.HR and finance suite. The I-9 is a business process inside onboarding.
PricingPublished pricing, tiered by hires per year, from $50 a month. Unlimited users, locations, E-Verify accounts, and API access, with no seat, location, or storage fees.Not published. Part of your Workday contract.
Remote Section 2Two paths on every plan: an authorized representative you choose (free), or our US-based team by secure video for $50. Live-video review requires E-Verify at the hiring site; we can enroll you and act as your E-Verify employer agent at no extra cost.Workday doesn't supply reviewers. Your managers or an authorized representative you arrange complete Section 2.
E-VerifyBuilt into every plan at no extra fee. Cases submit automatically when Section 2 is complete.Workday offers an E-Verify connector that creates the case when the employer finishes the I-9.
ReverificationAlerts at 180, 90, 60, and 30 days before work authorization expires, and flags who must not be reverified.A Supplement B business process that's started by hand. In the tenant we reviewed, the delivered expiring-documents report was labeled legacy.
HRIS integrationsPre-built Workday connector, plus proven custom integrations for SAP and other enterprise HR systems, built to your setup. The API is included on every plan; SFTP, iFrame, and SSO come with the Enterprise Package.Workday is the HR system.
Background checksAvailable through i9 Intelligence.
SupportUS-based compliance team by phone and email, Mon–Fri 8am–5pm CT. Tickets answered within 2 business hours.Workday support and your implementation partner. I-9 judgment calls stay with your HR team.
SwitchingManaged migration from any vendor, HCM, or paper, including older Form I-9 editions.Not needed. Workday stays your HR system, and new I-9s run in i9 Intelligence.
Audit recordField-level change history and audit-ready exports.In the tenant we reviewed, step-level process history only, and the delivered bulk export was I-9 PDFs without document copies or E-Verify details.

Prices exclude taxes. Our column reflects i9 Intelligence published pricing on the same date.

The I-9 is one business process in Workday

Workday delivers Form I-9 as business processes inside onboarding, with an E-Verify connector. In an HR suite that runs everything from payroll to performance reviews, the I-9 is one configuration among hundreds, and how well it works depends on how your tenant was set up.

When ICE asks for your I-9s

A Notice of Inspection gives an employer at least three business days to produce its Forms I-9 (8 CFR 274a.2(b)(2)(ii)). Workday delivers I-9 audit reports and a "Mass Print Form I-9 for Workers" report, and your HR team or Workday partner runs them and answers ICE. In the tenant we reviewed, the audit history logged process steps instead of changes to individual fields, and the mass print produced PDFs without document copies or E-Verify details. ICE's August 2026 fact sheet calls for electronic I-9s with a compliant audit trail, and 8 CFR 274a.2(g)(1)(iv) asks for a permanent record of every change. Our compliance team has helped employers through ICE audits since 1998. We pull your I-9s, review them with you before they go out, and help you correct what the rules allow. Our account reviews also flag open Section 2s, unresolved E-Verify cases, and forms past their retention date long before an audit.

What we saw completing an I-9 in Workday

In September 2026 we spent more than an hour in a customer's Workday tenant with their Workday consultant, working as the new hire, the manager, and HR. Configurations differ, so read this as one real setup rather than every Workday customer's.

Section 1 needed a Workday login, and it accepted a Social Security number starting with 900 and a date of birth from the current month. In Section 2, List A was filtered by citizenship status but Lists B and C weren't, so a U.S. citizen with an EAD under List C went through. Section 2 could be signed weeks after the first day with only an overdue reason to pick, and a rehire reused the original I-9 without a Supplement B.

Who answers the hard questions

Workday support and your implementation partner know the platform. The questions behind most I-9 violations aren't platform questions. A TPS holder whose country's designation was terminated or extended this year, an asylee or refugee presenting a Form I-94 instead of a card, a work permit covered by an automatic extension, a receipt, or an expiring document that has to be reverified on Supplement B all need someone who knows the rules. Reverification is a good example. Workday's Supplement B process has to be started by hand, and the delivered expiring-documents report in the tenant we reviewed was labeled "DO NOT USE – legacy." Calls to us go to the I-9 compliance team, who have handled exactly these cases since 1998.

The I-9s you already have

Changing I-9 systems doesn't end your duty to the old forms. Under 8 CFR 274a.2(e)(4)(ii), existing Forms I-9 have to stay accessible for as long as each one must be kept. One university's Workday guidance notes that I-9 data converted into Workday from a prior system would not be sufficient in an external audit. We migrate older I-9s into i9 Intelligence, including older editions and Supplement B history, so every form sits in one searchable place with its retention date tracked.

How the two work together

Workday stays your HR system. Our pre-built Workday connector brings new hires into i9 Intelligence so nobody retypes them, and the I-9, E-Verify, and reverification alerts run here. Our API is included on every plan, and single sign-on comes with our Enterprise Package for teams that want more.

Remote hires

Workday doesn't supply anyone to examine documents, so remote hires mean your managers or an authorized representative you arrange. On i9 Intelligence, a manager or representative you choose completes Section 2 at no extra cost, or our US-based team does it by video where the hiring site is enrolled in E-Verify (USCIS).

Where Workday is stronger

Every comparison we publish includes this. If one of these matters most to you, Workday may be the better fit.

  • Hiring, onboarding, payroll, and the employee record live in one system with one login.
  • There's no second vendor to buy, contract, or connect.
  • For in-person hiring with a well-tested configuration, the built-in I-9 may cover what you need.

Keep Workday. Add i9 Intelligence.

Workday stays your system of record. New hires flow from Workday into i9 Intelligence through our pre-built connector, and the Form I-9, E-Verify, and reverification run here with a compliance team behind them and every change recorded in one audit trail.

Integration:
Pre-built connector
How our integrations work →

Stays in

Workday

Hiring, onboarding, payroll, and the employee record

Runs in i9 Intelligence

Form I-9, E-Verify cases, reverification, ICE audit support, retention, and the audit trail

Common questions

Does Workday have a Form I-9 module?

Yes. Workday delivers Form I-9 as business processes inside onboarding, along with an E-Verify connector. What differs from a dedicated I-9 platform is how entries get checked, how reverification gets triggered, who answers the hard document questions, and what the audit record looks like when ICE asks for it.

Will Workday help if ICE audits our I-9s?

Workday delivers I-9 audit reports and a mass-print report, and your HR team or Workday partner runs them and responds to ICE. Workday doesn't describe reviewing your I-9s or working through an inspection with you. i9 Intelligence has helped employers through ICE audits since 1998, reviewing I-9s before they go to ICE and helping correct what the rules allow.

Do we have to leave Workday to use i9 Intelligence?

No. Workday stays your HR system, and our pre-built Workday connector brings new hires into i9 Intelligence, where the I-9, E-Verify, and reverification run.

What happens to the I-9s already in Workday?

They have to stay accessible for each form's full retention period. We can migrate them into i9 Intelligence so every form sits in one searchable place with its retention date tracked, and many employers coming from an HCM have us audit the older forms during the move.

Is Workday's I-9 enough for some employers?

It can be, for employers who hire in person, rarely need reverification, and have tested their I-9 business processes. The gaps show up in inspections, hard document cases, and reverification, which is usually when Workday customers call us.

Sources

We make i9 Intelligence. Found something out of date? Email support@i-9intelligence.com and we'll review and correct it.

Still deciding?

Fifteen minutes with a specialist. We'll look at how you hire and tell you honestly which setup fits, even if it isn't us.