Buyer's guide · Updated October 26, 2026

Best I-9 compliance software for 2026

For mid-size employers with remote hires, several sites, or an HR system's I-9 they've outgrown, the pick is i9 Intelligence, with a compliance team behind every I-9. The I-9 built into your HR system can be enough when trained HR staff complete every hire in person, and the sections below show where each of the other options fits.

We make i9 Intelligence, one of the options on this page. Competitor prices come from each vendor's own pricing page, and every head-to-head page lists its sources, the date we checked them, and where that competitor is stronger.

An i9 Intelligence compliance specialist on a video call with a new hire holding up an ID
Rated 5.0 on SHRM
US-based compliance team
Rated 5.0 on SHRM
Reviewed by HR teams on the SHRM vendor directory
E-Verify employer agent
We can enroll you and run E-Verify at no extra cost
0 customer fines
In 28 years of I-9 and E-Verify work
#1 at HRPresso
Top pick in its October 2026 review of seven I-9 and E-Verify tools
Quick picks

Which I-9 option fits how you hire

Find the row that sounds like you, and follow the name to its full comparison.

PickIf this sounds like youWhy it fits
i9 IntelligenceRemote I-9 Agent
Remote hires, several sites, or nobody trained to complete Section 2Our US-based team completes Section 2 by video, on the new hire's phone.
i9 IntelligenceWorkday connector and free API
You've outgrown the I-9 in Workday, ADP, Paycom, or PaylocityNew hires still start in your HR system, and the I-9 and E-Verify run with us.
i9 IntelligenceReverification
Work permits and other documents that expireAlerts from 180 days out, and our team can complete Supplement B by video.
i9 IntelligenceMigration and audit
Moving off paper or another vendor, or worried about an auditWe move every past I-9 with its audit trail, and our compliance team can review them before ICE asks.
Equifax I-9 HQI-9 software
You want a reviewer in person near every new hireAbout 2,000 locations for in-person Section 2.
Fragomen WorkRightBuilt by an immigration law firm
You already use Fragomen for visas and want the I-9 with the same firmFragomen attorneys handle complex cases, with UK and Australia right-to-work checks in the same platform.
WorkBrightOnboarding and I-9 software
Every new-hire form in one systemState tax forms, wage notices, and the I-9 together.
E-Verify+Free USCIS service
A few hires a year and no budgetFree from USCIS for employers who use E-Verify directly, not through an employer agent.
Three ways to do it

Three ways to get your I-9s done

Most of the choice comes down to who does the work, meaning who examines documents, who answers the hard cases, and who stands behind the file when ICE asks for it.

“You are liable for any violations in connection with the form or the verification process, including any violations committed by the authorized representative acting on your behalf.”
USCIS, M-274 Handbook for Employers, section 2.0
A compliance teami9 Intelligence The I-9 in your HR systemWorkday, ADP, Paycom, Gusto Software your team runsEquifax I-9 HQ, Tracker I-9, WorkBright, E-Verify+
Who completes Section 2 Our US-based team by videoOr your own staff, free on every plan Your managers at each site Your staffOr the vendor's network, for a fee per form
What you pay From $50 a monthPlus $50 per Section 2 our team completes Part of your HR contract Per form, or quoted after a demo
Fits best Remote or multi-site hiring, and employers who want a team behind the I-9 Every hire in person, with trained HR at each site Trained staff at each site who want better tools
Who answers TPS, receipt, and reverification questions Our compliance team Your HR team Your HR team, plus vendor support
The employer carries the fine with every option, so the safest choice is the one least likely to make a mistake. WorkBright+, Equifax I-9 Anywhere, and Tracker I-9 Pro sell their own done-for-you services, and the cost table below compares them.
Customer story

What a 100% turnkey I-9 and E-Verify program looks like

Global technology company
Every role hired remote
Interns to executives
Visa and work permit hires
The challenge

Every new hire works remote, and many arrive on visas, work permits, or foreign passports. Each of those I-9s needs a careful Section 2, and plenty need reverification later.

What we do

When they hire someone in Workday, our API integration opens the I-9 automatically, and our team handles every Section 2, E-Verify case, and reverification from there.

What we caught

None of their reverification records came over when they moved their I-9s out of Workday. We found the gap during the move, and every expiring work permit is tracked again.

“We do 100% of our Section 2s with i9 Intelligence. They are our outsourced I-9 team.”
Global Mobility team, global technology company
100%
of Section 2s, E-Verify cases, and reverifications run by our team
7+ weeks
of HR time back every year, at 20 minutes per Section 2 and reverification
HR teams that trust us with their I-9s
All options

Every I-9 option, side by side

Our product is listed first so you know where we stand, and each name links to a full comparison with its sources.

Prices as each vendor publishes them on the date at the top of this page, with applicable taxes added where required.

Vendor
Pricing
Remote Section 2
Fits best
I-9 and E-Verify specialist
Published. From $50 a month by hires per year, with E-Verify, unlimited users and locations, and the API included.
Our US-based team by video for $50, or free with an authorized representative you choose.
Remote or multi-site hiring, and employers who want a compliance team behind the I-9
Equifax
Specialist I-9 vendor
Monthly plan fee plus a fee per I-9. Enterprise is quoted.
Its network, in person or by video, $84.95 per form
Large in-person network needs; immigration case management
Gusto
HCM or payroll suite
I-9 included in payroll plans
Employee-chosen reviewer; $20 per check or included on Premium
Small businesses on Gusto hiring in person without E-Verify
Tracker I-9
Specialist I-9 vendor
Not published (custom quote)
I-9 Pro, its own experts over Zoom, priced per appointment; plus in-person centers
Large enterprises wanting audit support that includes legal consultation
WorkBright
Specialist I-9 vendor
Software quoted after a demo. WorkBright+ full service is $25 per I-9 with a $25,000 annual minimum.
Authorized representative with geo-validation, the DHS alternative procedure, or WorkBright+ full service
Employers who want all new-hire paperwork in one system
Workday's I-9 module
HCM or payroll suite
Not published. Part of your Workday contract.
Your managers or an authorized representative you arrange
Workday employers who hire in person with a tested I-9 configuration
Paycom
HCM or payroll suite
Not published. Quoted per employee per month.
Your team by video (E-Verify required) or a representative you arrange
Paycom employers who hire in person with experienced HR staff
Fragomen WorkRight
Specialist I-9 vendor
Quote-only. Lite, Core, and Enterprise tiers priced by hiring volume and program complexity.
WorkRight verification representatives by scheduled video session, or your own authorized representatives
Fragomen clients verifying workers in several countries
ADP
HCM or payroll suite
Not published. The I-9 is sold separately from ADP Onboarding.
A representative you arrange, or your team by video (E-Verify required)
ADP employers who hire in person with experienced HR staff
E-Verify+
Free USCIS service
Free
Your own staff, by live video
Employers already on E-Verify who hire a few people a year in person
What it costs

What a year costs when the vendor does Section 2

Remote Section 2 is usually the biggest line on the bill, so here's the yearly cost when the vendor's team completes every one, using each vendor's published prices.

Vendor50 hires a yearStarter plan at i9 Intelligence150 hires a yearGrowth+ plan at i9 Intelligence400 hires a yearBusiness plan at i9 Intelligence
i9 Intelligence$50 per Section 2 our team completes
$3,100$50 a month, plus 50 × $50$9,120$135 a month, plus 150 × $50$23,300$275 a month, plus 400 × $50
Equifax I-9 HQ$84.95 per outsourced I-9
$4,370Business Standard, plus 50 × $84.95$12,870Business Standard, plus 150 × $84.95$34,100Business Standard, plus 400 × $84.95
WorkBright+$25 per I-9, $25,000 yearly minimum
$25,000The yearly minimum, which covers 1,000 I-9s$25,000The yearly minimum, which covers 1,000 I-9s$25,000The yearly minimum, which covers 1,000 I-9s

i9 Intelligence uses the plan that covers your hires, with volume pricing from 500 hires a year, and Section 2s your own staff or an authorized representative complete cost nothing extra. Equifax uses I-9 HQ Business Standard, its first plan with E-Verify, billed annually. Vendor prices come from their own pricing pages on the date at the top of this page, with applicable taxes added where required.

Before you buy

When you might not need a compliance team

Most employers with remote hires or several sites need one, and these are the cases where a simpler setup does the job.

Every hire is in person, with trained HR

Your HR staff know the form, nobody hires remotely, and reverifications are rare.

The I-9 in your HR system can be enough, and we're here when that changes.

You want a reviewer on site

Some employers want a person to examine documents in person near each new hire, and our team works by live video.

An in-person network fits, and Equifax and Tracker run one.

You want every onboarding form in one system

Having state tax forms, wage notices, and the I-9 in one place matters more to you than who completes Section 2.

An onboarding suite fits, and WorkBright is built for it.

Vendor checklist

Eight questions to ask any I-9 vendor, us included

Most employers with remote hires or several sites need one, and these are the cases where a simpler setup does the job.

AskWhat a good answer sounds like
Who completes Section 2 for remote hires, and what does each one cost?
The options are your staff, an authorized representative you choose, an in-person network, or the vendor's own team by video, and live video review requires E-Verify at that hiring site.
Does it catch errors before the form is saved?
Field-level checks on Sections 1 and 2 do far more for you than a digital copy of the paper form.
Is E-Verify built in?
Cases should go out from the finished I-9 without retyping, with tentative nonconfirmations tracked until they're closed.
How does it handle reverification?
It should warn you well before work authorization expires and know who must never be reverified, such as U.S. citizens and permanent residents who presented a green card.
Can it produce an audit trail ICE will accept?
ICE's inspection fact sheet says electronic I-9s must be produced with a compliant audit trail, and 8 CFR 274a.2(e) through (i) sets the standards that trail has to meet.
What's the all-in price?
Ask about seat, location, per-form, E-Verify, storage, API, and setup fees, and whether you'll pay monthly for records already on file.
Can it connect to your HR system and bring over the I-9s you already have?
Ask what the API costs, which systems it already works with, and whether older form editions and Supplement B history come over with their audit trail.
Who answers the phone?
You'll want people who work on I-9 and E-Verify every day, because a general help desk usually can't settle a TPS or receipt question.
Questions

I-9 software questions we hear most

What is the best I-9 compliance software?

For employers with remote hires, several sites, or no trained HR at each location, i9 Intelligence is the strongest fit, because our US-based team completes Section 2 by video and E-Verify and the API come with every plan. Equifax I-9 HQ fits employers whose own staff complete every hire in person, and the I-9 in Workday, ADP, or Paycom can be enough when HR is experienced and nobody hires remotely.

How much does I-9 software cost?

i9 Intelligence plans start at $50 a month for up to 50 hires a year, with E-Verify, unlimited users, and the API included. Equifax charges a monthly plan fee plus a fee for each I-9, and Tracker, Fragomen WorkRight, and the HR suites quote their prices. The bigger cost is usually remote Section 2, and the cost table on this page compares it across three vendors at three hiring volumes.

Does the government certify I-9 software?

No. Joint DOJ and ICE guidance from December 2023 says the federal government doesn't approve, endorse, or certify any Form I-9 software, and the employer stays responsible for its forms whatever system it uses. Electronic I-9 systems have to meet the standards in 8 CFR 274a.2(e) through (i).

Can someone else complete Section 2 for a remote hire?

Yes, in two ways. An authorized representative you choose can examine the documents in person, or, when you're enrolled in E-Verify and in good standing at that hiring site, documents can be examined over live video under the DHS alternative procedure. Vendors such as i9 Intelligence, Equifax, Tracker, and WorkBright will run that video review for you.

Is the I-9 in Workday, ADP, or Paycom enough?

It can be, when every hire is in person and your HR staff know the form well. Employers usually add a specialist when remote hires start, when a self-audit turns up errors, or when nobody on staff wants to own the TPS, receipt, and reverification questions. We have a pre-built Workday connector and proven custom integrations for enterprise customers, so new hires can start in your HR system while the I-9 runs with us.

How much does remote I-9 verification cost?

Our team's remote verification is $50 per hire, with the E-Verify case included. It's an add-on to any plan, billed only for completed verifications, with volume pricing from 500 hires a year. Section 2 by your own staff or by someone the new hire picks costs nothing extra.

Is there a free I-9 API?

Yes. i9 Intelligence includes its REST API on every plan, so your HR system or ATS can start an I-9 and pull back I-9 and E-Verify status at no extra cost. Ask other vendors what API access costs, since several keep integrations for their enterprise plans.

Is this guide neutral?

We make i9 Intelligence, so no, and we say so at the top. Competitor prices come from each vendor's own pricing page, and each head-to-head page lists its sources, the date we checked them, and where the competitor is stronger. If something's out of date, email support@i-9intelligence.com and we'll fix it.

How we checked

Sources and head-to-head comparisons

We re-checked each vendor's pricing page on October 26, 2026, used only the prices they publish, and did the cost math ourselves. Other competitor facts come from vendor product pages and help centers, public filings, and review sites. The points about remote Section 2 and support also draw on conversations with employers who moved to us from these vendors, and each head-to-head page carries its own sources and the date we checked them.

8 CFR 274a.2(e) through (i), standards for electronic Form I-9 systems
‍
DOJ and ICE joint guidance on Form I-9 software, December 19, 2023
‍
ICE fact sheet on Form I-9 inspections, updated August 31, 2026
‍
‍
Equifax I-9 HQ plans page; WorkBright pricing page; Tracker I-9 by Mitratech product pages; Gusto pricing page; Workday, ADP, and Paycom product pages; Fragomen WorkRight website; USCIS E-Verify+ employer guide. The third-party review cited is HRPresso's “Best I-9 and E-Verify Software in 2026” (October 2026).

We make i9 Intelligence, so if you find something out of date, email support@i-9intelligence.com and we'll review and correct it.

Not sure which fits? Ask our compliance team

Spend fifteen minutes with our compliance team and we'll tell you honestly which setup fits, even when the answer is your HR system or another vendor.

Or call us at (713) 668-6200.

What happens after you book

1
Tell us how you hire

Where people start work, how many you hire a year, and what you use for I-9s today.

2
We tell you what fits

Even when the answer is the I-9 in your HR system or another vendor on this page.

3
We set you up when we're the fit

We move your existing I-9s over and turn on E-Verify for every site.