5 Common I-9 Compliance Pitfalls in Agriculture

The agricultural industry faces a unique set of compliance challenges when it comes to managing Form I-9s. With seasonal hiring cycles, a diverse workforce, and evolving federal requirements like E-Verify, even well-intentioned employers can find themselves at risk of non-compliance.

Here are five of the most common pitfalls agriculture businesses run into with I-9s—and practical steps to help stay compliant and audit-ready.

1. Navigating E-Verify Requirements

While E-Verify is voluntary for many employers, it’s mandatory in certain states and for federal contractors—including some agricultural operations. The confusion often lies in when, where, and how to use E-Verify, especially across multi-state operations.

Tip: If your business operates in states with different E-Verify laws, make sure your hiring practices are segmented accordingly.

2. Managing a Seasonal Workforce

Agriculture’s seasonal hiring patterns create pressure to onboard quickly, which can lead to mistakes—or skipped steps—in I-9 completion. Rehiring former workers adds another layer of complexity: do you reuse an old I-9 or start fresh?

Tip: Understand the 3-year/3-day rule: you can reuse an existing I-9 if the original is less than 3 years old and the rehire is within 3 years. But updates may still be needed.

3. Missing I-9 Purge Deadlines

Many agricultural businesses store I-9s indefinitely, unaware of the federal retention rules. Holding onto outdated I-9s can unnecessarily expose your company to liability in the event of an audit.

Tip: Employers must retain I-9s either 3 years after the hire date or 1 year after termination, whichever is later.  

4. Tracking Expiring Work Authorization

With a workforce that may include temporary visa holders or individuals with expiring documents, employers must be vigilant about re-verification. Missed deadlines for re-verification can result in employment of unauthorized workers—and penalties.

Tip: Implement a document tracking system that flags upcoming expirations. A digital solution like i9 Intelligence sends automated alerts so nothing slips through the cracks.

5. Handling Receipts and Supporting Documents

When employees provide a receipt in place of an original document—such as a lost Social Security card—employers must follow up and replace it within the required timeframe. But this step is often missed during busy hiring seasons.

Tip: Receipts are only valid for 90 days. Failing to follow up can result in incomplete I-9s and put you at risk during an audit.

Why It Pays to Get I-9 Compliance Right

Agriculture employers have enough challenges to manage—compliance shouldn't be one of them. DHS audits don’t discriminate based on industry, and penalties for I-9 violations can reach thousands of dollars per employee, even for technical errors.

That’s where i9 Intelligence comes in.

Our cloud-based platform is built to handle the real-world needs of agricultural operations: fast onboarding, mobile access for remote worksites, automated document tracking, and built-in E-Verify integration. We make it easier to stay compliant, reduce risk, and prepare confidently for audits—no matter how complex your workforce may be.

Because at the end of the day, it's not just about forms—it's about protecting your business and the people who keep it running.

Whether you’re managing onboarding for a small farm or a large-scale operation, I-9 Intelligence gives you the tools to do it right—the first time. Let us help you make I-9 compliance one less thing to worry about.

‍